Cane

This social monitoring data presents the opinions of cane growers engaged in practice change projects to reduce sediment, nutrients and pesticides being lost to local waterways.

During 2021 and 2022, many growers engaged in practice change projects, with over 590 responses to before and after surveys about their practice change journey from 10 sugarcane practice change projects.

Not all cane farmers completed both surveys, so the graphs may represent different respondents and are not directly comparable.

The practice change projects in 2021 and 2022 were different to the projects from 2020 which means that cane growers’ perceptions of the practices are not directly comparable across years.

Prior to completing the survey, the cane grower is asked to select if they are changing their fertiliser, pesticide, soil or irrigation management. Most cane farmers selected ‘changing my fertiliser management’ which encompasses a range of different practices, all contributing to reducing loss of nutrients from the farm in run-off to local waterways. The quantity of data varies across the practices and in some cases was below the threshold, so data were aggregated.

Attitudes

Holding positive or negative views on doing something can influence whether we will do it. This data tells us how positive or negative cane growers’ views are of the practice change.

Cane growers responded to the statement "I think this farming practice is a positive thing to do on my farm.”

Before

ResponseNumber of responses
Strongly agree 128
Agree 178
Neither agree nor disagree8
Disagree23
Strongly disagree 7
Don't know 10
No response 3

357 cane growers answered this question at the start of their project in relation to their specific practice (e.g. changing my fertiliser management, etc.)

After

Response Number of responses
Strongly agree 91
Agree 125
Neither agree nor disagree 9
Disagree 4
Strongly disagree 1
Don't know 5
No response 2

237 cane growers answered this question at the end of their project in relation to their specific practice (e.g., changing my fertiliser management, etc.)

Confidence

Our view of how easy something is for us to do can influence whether we do it. This data tells us how easy or difficult growers think a practice may be to use on farms.

Cane growers responded to the statement “I feel that this farming practice is easy to do on my farm.”

Before

ResponseNumber of responses
Strongly agree 54
Agree 176
Neither agree nor disagree 34
Disagree 45
Strongly disagree 2
Don't know 45
No response 1

357 cane growers answered this question at the start of their project in relation to their specific practice (e.g. changing my fertiliser management, etc.)

After

Response Number of responses
Strongly agree 49
Agree 158
Neither agree nor disagree 16
Disagree 9
Strongly disagree 0
Don't know 5
No response 0

237 cane growers answered this question at the end of their project in relation to their specific practice (e.g. changing my fertiliser management, etc.)

Motivations

Identifying the benefits that attract cane farmers to practice change helps us understand what is important to them. Different motivations are not inherently ‘bad’ or ‘good’. Variations in the most common motivations over time may reflect broader industry changes.

Cane growers selected up to three of their main motivations for making a practice change.

Before

Topic Number of responses
Government funding 41
Increased profitability 177
Increased production 130
To save money 63
To save time 111
To comply with regulations 211
Benefit local water quality 58
Benefit the environment 65
For my family 8
Other landholders 1
No reasons to change 1
Don't know1
No response0
Other18

357 cane growers answered this question at the start of their project in relation to their specific practice (e.g. changing my fertiliser management, etc.)

After

TopicNumber of responses
Government funding 16
Increased profitability 116
Increased production 83
To save time 28
To save money 72
To comply with regulations 155
Benefit local water quality 36
Benefit the environment 53
For my family 4
Other landholders 1
No reasons to change 0
Don't know0
No response0
Other14

237 cane growers answered this question at the end of their project in relation to their specific practice (e.g. changing my fertiliser management, etc.)

Barriers

The more obstacles that people think might get in the way of being able to do something, the less willing they may be to do it. This data tells us about what can make practice change more difficult for cane growers and helps us identify opportunities to remove those obstacles.

Cane growers selected up to three of their main barriers to making a practice change.

Before

Response Number of responses
Worried about production 113
Worried about profitability 96
Don’t have the time 53
Need more information 42
Costs too much 78
No water quality benefit 15
Not how I manage my farm 11
Weather and seasonal issues 86
Lack of family support 4
Tried it before and wasn’t happy 1
Constrained by contractors 8
No challenges/difficulties 55
Don’t know 6
No response 5
Other 45

357 cane growers answered this question at the start of their project in relation to their specific practice (e.g. changing my fertiliser management, etc.)

After

Response Number of responses
Worried about production 76
Worried about profitability 64
Don’t have the time 30
Need more information 12
Costs too much 36
No water quality benefit 13
Not how I manage my farm 7
Weather and seasonal issues 50
Lack of family support 1
Tried it before and wasn’t happy 2
Constrained by contractors 8
No challenges/difficulties 51
Don’t know 1
No response 6
Other 28

237 cane growers answered this question at the end of their project in relation to their specific practice (e.g. changing my fertiliser management, etc.)